If I said I’m in favour of these types of fishing waters you may be surprised. I’ve thought about them for a long time, and on the whole come down on the side they are good for our future fishing. However you may be surprised when I tell you why I think that way?
On the selfish side, it keeps the Match angler off the wild waters. I really hate the way our fish are treated by the majority of these anglers, during and after the matches. I’ve witnesses the “way-in’s” after a match, and the fish treatment is shocking. During Matches fish treatment is not much better, fish being thrown, dropped into the keep-nets because speed is of the utmost importance. On wild waters that fish damage affects me, on Commercials it doesn’t, simple. Watch the way in river match? Could we not improve this system of weighing in? I think we could.
On Commercials they have keep-net limit rules that are not in-forced, so carp (mostly carp) are damaged in the crowded net. I’ve fished a few Commercials and the fish quality is abysmal. Broken fins, damaged mouths, open sores, missing scales, if they were humans it would be called torture. I know for a fact that several Match-men really do care about the fish they catch, but they are in the minority, and when they speak out, they get lambasted. There will come a time when all anglers will be judged by their (match-man) actions by the fishing hating community, and we will all deserve it, as we do nothing to educate people to better understand fish handling.
If you click on You-Tube coarse fishing, 90% of the videos are now about dozens of blokes sat around a little pond catching carp. They teach you how to cast, set up a feeder rod, float rods, pellet wagglers, reviews on poles, reels, seats everything apart from fish care. For my self I cannot see any enjoyment in fishing a puddle stuffed full of fish, it’s just too easy. But that’s what these people want, easy fishing, so it works for me as most of them stay away from my spots, as they cannot catch wild fish.
Good handling means this little Commercial Carp goes back with little trouble. A decent net, and weigh mat.
If you think I’m angry about this subject your right. Too many good ponds, and lakes have been stocked with Carp that could not normally support them-selves without anglers baits. The fish are hungry all the time, having to feed regardless of the cost to their well-being. This artificial stocking has ruined true fishing for many, knowing you will always catch regardless of how inept you are, sad isn’t it?